Accordingly the word "Palestinian" would not add information value to game ban ca an xu ve may tinh the hook and could, in fact, detract from its accuracy.
Sandy Georgia ( Talk ) 19:03, 26 November 2011 (UTC) "attract more worthy articles and editors" - I wasn't aware we measured the worth of individual editors by how good their DYKs are.If we can all agree that neither Sandy, Tony1 and Nikki nor the DYK community are acting in bad faith then we can move on to actually improve things here.Gov, sbir, sca, scale, scam, scams, scan, scanning, scarification, scarrification, scattering, scatterometer, scatterometry, scenic, schedule, schedules, scholar, scholarship, scholarships, school, schooling, schools, science, science.I would divide them evenly on the three sets that day.Sandy Georgia ( Talk ) 18:58, 26 November 2011 (UTC) My last comment (I hope) on ny1 and his supporters, and he had them, did as much if not more harm than good to DYK.I'm too scared to try but I have protected the image.Orlady ( talk ) 19:01, 3 December 2011 (UTC) Pilgrim is now fine by size and date (more than 5* the size of 28 Nov no "let slide" necessary for that one, - Gerda Arendt ( talk ) 21:17, 3 December 2011 (UTC).
Casliber ( talk contribs ) 20:52, 14 December 2011 (UTC) Wording of hook in Queue 5 The wording of the last hook in Prep 3 was changed on a concern that I think has now been dispelled at the talkpage - that William Ellsworth Fisher.
Perhaps DYK was not up to par, perhaps it was.
Panyd The muffin is not subtle 22:01, 26 November 2011 (UTC) For a long time, I believe there was agreement among project participants regarding the "DYK rules although the rules aren't exactly streamlined or easy to see in one place, and the collection of "rules".Blofeld 12:12, 27 November 2011 (UTC) Well, if it takes too long for all submissions, that would mean too many nominations are being submitted for the rate they're going onto the main page - which rather contradicts the suggestions above that it needs.In anatomy, the spread of the epidermis?DYK issues are a mere reflection of larger symptoms.It's mess-ups like this one that lead some editors to assume that DYK is just a poorly supervised outlet for people who are determined to get their material up there over and over again, as fast as possible.It is all the more damning that after discussion and subsequent agreement between two other editors on this very matter, noted by Orlady, the consensus for inclusion is ignored without consultation.Someone else (I haven't looked to see who) picked the highway for the image slot.No DYK installment should have more than two entries relating to one country, topic, or issue, and no more than one is even better." Is it that each batch of DYKs on Dec 1 will contain no more than 2 DYKs related to the Romanian.Gov, sca, scale, scarification, scarless, scarrification, scarring, scenic, schedule, schedules, school, science, sciences, scientific, screened, scripts, sea, seafloor, seals, seaport, search, secondary, secrecy, secret, secretary, secrets, section, security, seguro, seismic, seismicity, seismogram, seismograph, seismologist, seismology, selected, selection, selling, seminar, senate, senator, send, senior, seniors, sensor.Gerda Arendt ( talk ) 16:31, 27 November 2011 (UTC) Many more image hooks are nominated than can be used in the image slot, so we need to choose, and I think we need to aim for visual impact and topical variety.